Werner's Theory and It's Limitations


Werner's Theory

In 1893, Werner produced a theory to explain the structures, formation and nature of bonding in the coordination compounds. This theory is known as Werner's theory of coordination compounds.

Some important postulates of this theory are given below-

  1. The central metal atoms in coordination compounds show two types of valency. first one is the primary valency (Principal or Ionizable) and the second one is the secondary valency (Auxiliary or non-Ionizable).
  2. The primary valency relates to the oxidation state and the secondary valency relates to the coordinate number.
  3. The number of secondary valences is fixed for every metal atom. that means the coordination number is fixed.
  4. Central metal atom satisfy both its primary and secondary valencies. Primary valency is satisfied by negative ion whereas secondary valancies are satisfied by negative ion or by neutral molecules.
  5. The secondary valancies are always directed towards fixed position in space and this cause definite geometry of the coordinate compound. For examples: If a metal ion has six secondary valencies, these are arranged octahedrally around the central metal ion. If the metal ion has four secondary valencies, these are arranged in either tetrahedral or square planar arrangement around the central metal ion. The secondary valency thus determines the stereochemistry of the complex ion. While the primary valency is non-directional.
  6. The secondary valencies are generally represented by solid lines while the primary valencies are represented by dashed lines and the ions which satisfy both primary and secondary valencies will be drawn with both solid and dashed lines.

Limitations of Werne'rs Theory

  1. It could not explain the inability of all elements to form coordination compounds.
  2. The Werners theory could not explain the directional properties of bonds in various coordination compounds.
  3. It does not explain the colour, the magnetic and optical properties shown by coordination compounds.

Test Your Knowledge: Werner's Theory

1. According to the postulates of Werner's theory for coordination compounds.
  • (A) Primary valency is ionizable
  • (B) Secondary valency is ionizable
  • (C) Primary and secondary valencies are non-ionizable
  • (D) Only primary valency is non-ionizable
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (A) Primary valency is ionizable

The primary valency corresponds to the oxidation state of the central metal ion. It is satisfied by negative ions (anions) that readily dissociate or ionize when the complex dissolves in a solution.

2. Which of the following postulates of Werner's theory is incorrect?
  • (A) Secondary valence is equal to the coordination number and it depends upon the nature of ligand attached to metal.
  • (B) The ions/groups bound by the secondary linkages to the metal have characteristic spatial arrangements.
  • (C) Primary valencies are satisfied by negative ions.
  • (D) None of these
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (A) Secondary valence is equal to the coordination number and it depends upon the nature of ligand attached to metal.

This statement is incorrect because the secondary valency is fixed for a given metal ion and does not depend on the nature of the ligand. It defines the coordination number and spatial arrangement of ligands around the central atom.

3. When AgNO3 is added to a solution of Co(NH3)3Cl3, the precipitate of AgCl shows two ionisable chloride ions. This means:
  • (A) Two chlorine atoms satisfy primary valency and one secondary valency
  • (B) One chlorine atom satisfies primary as well as secondary valency
  • (C) Three chlorine atoms satisfy primary valency
  • (D) Three chlorine atoms satisfy secondary valency
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (A) Two chlorine atoms satisfy primary valency and one secondary valency

Since only two chloride ions are ionisable, they must be outside the coordination sphere (primary valency). The third chloride is coordinated to the metal through secondary valency and is not ionisable.

4. According to Werner's theory, the geometry of the complex is determined by:
  • (A) Only from the primary valence in space
  • (B) Number and position of the primary valences in space
  • (C) Number and position of the secondary valences in space
  • (D) Only from the position of secondary valence in space
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (C) Number and position of the secondary valences in space

The geometry of a coordination complex is dictated by the secondary valencies, which correspond to the coordination number and spatial arrangement of ligands around the central metal ion.

5. Which of the following statements correctly distinguishes primary and secondary valencies in Werner's theory?
  • (A) Primary valencies are ionizable, secondary valencies are non-ionizable
  • (B) Both primary and secondary valencies are ionizable
  • (C) Primary valencies are non-ionizable, secondary valencies are ionizable
  • (D) Both primary and secondary valencies are non-ionizable
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (A) Primary valencies are ionizable, secondary valencies are non-ionizable

Primary valencies correspond to oxidation states and are satisfied by anions that ionize in solution. Secondary valencies correspond to coordination number and are satisfied by ligands bound directly to the metal, hence non-ionizable.

6. Which experimental evidence first supported Werner’s theory of coordination compounds?
  • (A) Measurement of molar conductivity of complexes
  • (B) X-ray diffraction studies of crystal structures
  • (C) Colorimetric analysis of transition metal complexes
  • (D) Magnetic susceptibility measurements
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (B) X-ray diffraction studies of crystal structures

Werner’s predictions about spatial arrangements of ligands were confirmed by X-ray crystallography, which revealed octahedral and square planar geometries consistent with his theory.

7. According to Werner’s theory, the coordination number of a metal ion is determined by:
  • (A) The number of primary valencies satisfied
  • (B) The number of secondary valencies satisfied
  • (C) The oxidation state of the metal
  • (D) The ionic radius of the metal ion
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (B) The number of secondary valencies satisfied

The coordination number is defined by the number of ligands directly attached to the central metal ion via secondary valencies, not by the oxidation state or ionic radius alone.

8. Which of the following complexes illustrates the concept of ionizable primary valency?
  • (A) [Co(NH3)6]Cl3
  • (B) [CoCl3(NH3)3]
  • (C) [Pt(NH3)2Cl2]
  • (D) [Fe(CN)6]3−
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (A) [Co(NH3)6]Cl3

In this complex, three chloride ions are outside the coordination sphere, satisfying primary valency. They are ionizable and precipitate as AgCl when treated with AgNO3.

9. Which type of isomerism in coordination compounds is explained directly by Werner’s theory?
  • (A) Optical isomerism
  • (B) Geometrical isomerism
  • (C) Linkage isomerism
  • (D) Ionization isomerism
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (D) Ionization isomerism

Ionization isomerism arises when ligands exchange between the coordination sphere and the ionizable sphere, a concept directly predicted by Werner’s distinction between primary and secondary valencies.

10. Which of the following best describes the spatial arrangement of ligands in Werner’s theory?
  • (A) Determined by primary valencies only
  • (B) Determined by secondary valencies and defines geometry
  • (C) Random arrangement around the central atom
  • (D) Determined by both primary and secondary valencies equally
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (B) Determined by secondary valencies and defines geometry

Secondary valencies correspond to the coordination number and dictate the geometry of the complex (octahedral, tetrahedral, square planar, etc.), while primary valencies only determine ionization.

11. Which of the following complexes exhibits ionization isomerism?
  • (A) [Co(NH3)5Br]SO4 and [Co(NH3)5SO4]Br
  • (B) [Pt(NH3)2Cl2] and [Pt(NH3)2Br2]
  • (C) [Fe(CN)6]3− and [Fe(CN)6]4−
  • (D) [CoCl3(NH3)3] and [CoCl2(NH3)4]
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (A) [Co(NH3)5Br]SO4 and [Co(NH3)5SO4]Br

Ionization isomerism occurs when ligands exchange between the coordination sphere and the ionizable sphere, leading to different ions in solution.

12. Which geometry is most commonly associated with coordination number 6 in Werner’s theory?
  • (A) Tetrahedral
  • (B) Square planar
  • (C) Octahedral
  • (D) Trigonal bipyramidal
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (C) Octahedral

Coordination number 6 typically corresponds to an octahedral arrangement of ligands around the central metal ion, as predicted by Werner’s theory.

13. Which limitation of Werner’s theory was later addressed by Crystal Field Theory?
  • (A) Failure to explain ionization isomerism
  • (B) Inability to explain magnetic and spectral properties of complexes
  • (C) Lack of distinction between primary and secondary valencies
  • (D) Incorrect prediction of coordination numbers
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (B) Inability to explain magnetic and spectral properties of complexes

Werner’s theory explained bonding and geometry but could not account for electronic properties such as magnetism and color. Crystal Field Theory later addressed these limitations.

14. Which of the following complexes is expected to show geometrical isomerism?
  • (A) [Pt(NH3)2Cl2]
  • (B) [Co(NH3)6]3+
  • (C) [Fe(CN)6]4−
  • (D) [Ni(CO)4]
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (A) [Pt(NH3)2Cl2]

This square planar complex can exist in cis and trans forms, demonstrating geometrical isomerism.

15. Which statement best summarizes the contribution of Werner’s theory to coordination chemistry?
  • (A) It explained the magnetic properties of transition metal complexes.
  • (B) It introduced the concept of primary and secondary valencies, laying the foundation for modern coordination chemistry.
  • (C) It described ligand field splitting in d-orbitals.
  • (D) It explained the thermodynamics of complex formation.
View Answer & Explanation
Correct Answer: (B) It introduced the concept of primary and secondary valencies, laying the foundation for modern coordination chemistry.

Werner’s theory was pioneering because it established the distinction between ionizable and non-ionizable valencies, predicting coordination numbers and geometries that remain central to coordination chemistry today.

Hi, Welcome to Maxbrain Chemistry.
Join Telegram Channel to get latest updates.
Join Now

Daily
Quiz